• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Paulie’s Pizza & Wings

Welcome to Paulie’s Pizza & Wings, where hearty flavors meet comforting traditions. Located in Tenafly, NJ, we combine the best of pizza and wings in a family-friendly atmosphere. Our dedication to quality ingredients shines through in every dish, from our classic cheese pizza to the rich, Old Fashion Sicilian Pizza. Don’t miss our signature Garlic Knots, a perfect appetizer, or our homemade lasagna, renowned for its taste. With amenities like outdoor seating, catering options, and a vibrant happy hour, Paulie's is an ideal gathering spot for friends and families alike. Join us and experience a slice of happiness today!

Paulie’s Pizza & Wings: Reviews & Ratings

Nathan Folk
Nathan Folk

I ordered plane pizza and garlic knots for delivery it took about 15 minutes. The knots are to die for. The pizza was just as good. I went there another time and it was excellent service. It took 3 minutes for me to get my pizza and it was ...

Blanca Soto
Blanca Soto

Also such a great experience at Paulines. Just good service and just as good as the food 1010

Wani R
Wani R

4.5 stars. I grew up in Englewood and now live on the border of Tenafly. I had eaten at Paulies a lot in my teens. ...

J. David Feeback
J. David Feeback

Ive tried the other pizza places in town and havent been impressed. Let me start by saying I dont like thick dough as my pizza crust. The other locations around town dont have flavor in the pizza sauce itself, they taste like simply ...

DongFang DJ huang
DongFang DJ huang

Yes, the best margarita Pizza I have in NJ . The boss is so nice!

Byron Herald
Byron Herald

I came into the pizzeria looking for something cold to drink. Pizza looked good and the employees were welcoming. I went with the Sicilian slice, nice and hot. Good move coming in here.

Amanda Collins
Amanda Collins

The pepperoni roll was the size of my arm. Every bite was amazingly delicious. Gobs of cheese and thick bites of pepperoni! Comes with tasty marinara.

Huaying Li
Huaying Li

Five star food and service. We have ordered margarita pizza and chicken parmigiana from Paulies today for lunch. Everything was so delicious and portion was really big too even for family of four. Still have the pasta came with chicken parm in my fridge. lol

Location

Introducing Paulie’s Pizza & Wings: A Slice of Heaven in Tenafly, NJ

Hidden away on Washington Street in Tenafly, New Jersey, Paulie’s Pizza & Wings is a culinary gem that specializes in classic pizza and mouth-watering chicken wings. This restaurant is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a community hub that warms the heart and fills the belly with comfort food.

What to Expect

  • Versatile Dining Options: Whether you're craving the cozy atmosphere of indoor seating or the refreshing breeze from outdoor dining, Paulie’s provides it all. The venue is also wheelchair accessible, catering to a diverse clientele.
  • Convenient Services: From delivery and takeout to reservations, they ensure you can enjoy their offerings wherever you are. Plus, the restaurant is equipped with Wi-Fi and offers catering services, making it ideal for gatherings.
  • Kid-Friendly Environment: With moderate noise levels and a welcoming staff, it’s a great spot for families seeking an enjoyable meal together.
  • Happy Hour Specials: For those looking to unwind, the happy hour specials offer a perfect opportunity to relax with a drink as you savor your meal.

Highlights of the Menu

Paulie’s menu is a delightful exploration of flavors that pays homage to classic Italian-American cuisine. Start with their 4 Piece Garlic Knots, which are fluffy dough tied in knots, baked to golden perfection, and topped with a decadent mix of butter, garlic, and parsley. Don’t forget to pair them with the rich tomato sauce that enhances every bite.

Moving onto the mains, the Chicken Parmesan Hero is a must-try. The juicy chicken is enveloped in rich marinara and melted cheese, all nested within a soft hero roll. Meanwhile, the Buffalo Chicken option promises a spicy kick with its marinated chicken topped with fresh veggies and a choice of creamy blue cheese or ranch dressing. Each bite is a burst of flavor that leaves you wanting more.

Decadent Desserts

No meal at Paulie’s is complete without indulging in their heavenly desserts. The Spumoni Tartufo showcases layers of chocolate and vanilla gelato, while the Tiramisu offers a rich and creamy experience that feels like a hug in dessert form. Thin, crispy Fried Oreos and delightful Mini Cannolis are also available for those craving a sweet ending to their meal.

Final Thoughts

Paulie’s Pizza & Wings is not just a restaurant; it’s an experience. The friendly atmosphere, delicious food, and commitment to quality make it an ideal choice for any occasion—from a casual family dinner to a night out with friends. For anyone in the Tenafly area looking for a slice of heaven, look no further than Paulie’s.

Contact Information: For reservations or inquiries, call (201) 567-9099.